Source:
TV Guide [follow link for complete column]
TV GUIDE: Ask Matt: Game of Thrones, Rectify, Orphan Black, Americans, Following, Good Wife
May 6, 2013
by
Matt Roush
Send questions and comments to
askmatt@tvguidemagazine.com and follow on
Twitter!
Question: Looking at the Best Drama shortlist from last year as an example, do you think many of the usual suspects like
Mad Men and
Breaking Bad may have their best days behind them (maybe not so much objectively as much as in short-attentioned minds of many voters), along with
Homeland seeming to have edged ever-so-slightly into ludicrousness (get pacemaker serial number and induce heart attack, all without Chloe opening a socket),
Downton Abbey now having a "perennial obligatory nominee" vibe, and
Boardwalk Empire maybe not even deserving to make the final cut anymore, could this be the year that
Game of Thrones finally breaks out of the fantasy ghetto and gets enough votes to have its name called when the big envelope is opened?
Scenes so far this year involving Lannisters sitting across a table from and talking to (or yelling at) each other are among the most enjoyable I've seen from any show all season. Thrilling scenes such as Dany acquiring her army of soon-to-be freed slaves, the Night's Watch rebellion and the Hound's trial by combat leave the viewer breathless. Quietly mesmerizing speeches such as Jaime confessing to a selfless act that saved thousands but was dubiously honored with "
Kingslayer" for his trouble (all while holding his stump in front of him, reminding us that, yes, the show actually did go there). And since producers have kept the broad strokes close to
George R.R. Martin's original story, there's no reason not to expect many viewers to require oral surgery by the end of the season given how hard jaws will hit the floor as the events those of us who are reading ahead are giddily awaiting will finally come to pass. In spite of passing within shouting distance of crazytown, I still think
Homeland had a very good season, I'd say that
Breaking Bad has not shown a dropoff in quality, I believe that
Justified reached and arguably exceeded the greatness of season 2, and although those are the only dramas that come close,
Game of Thrones leaves them all in the dust. Now that we're close to the end of the current TV season, how do you think
Game of Thrones stacks up this year? —
Mike
Matt Roush: This has been a remarkable season so far for
Game of Thrones for all of the reasons you so cleverly articulate. It absolutely deserves the Emmy nods it will get, and if the momentum continues as we expect it to, up to and including the "events" you hint at thankfully without spoiling,
Thrones could end up a front-runner, and wouldn't that be great.
Mad Men for me is only now starting to catch fire this season, and between
Breaking Bad's incomplete half-season (to me, a corporate misstep on
AMC's part to split the final season into two) and
Homeland's lurch into ludicrousness in the second half of the season, this does present an opportunity for
Thrones. I would take issue that
Downton Abbey's inclusion among the top dramas is a rubber-stamped inevitability. Few current dramas bring such joy to so many, and I'd hate to see it ignored. Ditto
The Good Wife, which had another tremendous season. I'd also like to see
FX's The Americans acknowledged for its smart, taut first season, although maybe not at the expense of
Justified. And then there's
Rectify, which like
Breaking Bad suffers from feeling incomplete with only six hours in the first season.
But back to
Thrones' chances of winning: Just as it took the
Lord of the Rings movies several tries before winning the big Oscar, there is a sense now that
Thrones at its best — and this season it is at its best — transcends genre and is so magnificently produced that it deserves to be taken very seriously as a contender...
Game of Thrones airs Sunday at 9/8C on
HBO.
CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE EPISODE TRAILER FOR 'THE BEAR AND THE MAIDEN FAIR,' AIRING MAY 12, 2013.
